Friday, January 3, 2014

My recent good fortune

This blog would be more active if my compulsion to write produced more concrete rewards than the pleasure of having strung words together. Much of my creative energies these days are necessarily channeled into work which pays bills. Word-smithing is useful there, too, but not nearly as enjoyable as free ranging over the page and following the mind as it wanders at will. I have much to say on this topic, am drafting some crude atheist material probably best delivered as stand-up...but this is a fine philosophical place to play with ideas that are not necessarily funny.

In the past month, I have lost a number of things. A cat that was given to me escaped the first night. On a journey with my family abroad, my wallet fell out of my pocket while juggling my squirming son. On the way home, my wife couldn't find her green card. And then on the flight home, I left two bottles of booze (mine) and two cartons of smokes (for a friend) in the overhead. I felt both stupid and unlucky. I imagined a happy cleaning crew enjoying the liquor and smokes (and wasn't too pissed about that image, actually- Happy New Year!). I imagined someone pocketing the cash out of the wallet. I imagined spending the night in a hotel and making desperate pleas in the Embassy for an emergency travel document, leveraging my fragile (at the time) health and my son's fever.

After some panicked running around to officials who had no answers, my wife did a second search of secret places in bags and it turns out it was only misplaced. The security guys found my booze and turned it in, and I convinced the airline to let me check it without a fee. The same afternoon (it was a 10 hour layover), I got a call that a crew in a completely different city from my itinerary found my wallet between the cushions- after the security crew at my airport had found nothing. And tonight I saw the missing cat in my yard- now working on seducing him with offerings of canned food.

What does this have to do with atheism? Well, just that shit happens- good shit and bad shit- and that it sometimes happens in clusters. If I were religious, I probably would have prayed at these various misfortunes (not sure about praying for the recovery of booze and smokes, but fuck- Jesus didn't turn the water into Kool-Aid). And I might have regarded the rapid succession of finding lost things as God looking out for me, answering my prayers. But I didn't pray, and I got all my stuff back anyway. I can hear the saved, washed in the blood sorts saying that God loves me too, so that's why He was so nice to me, or some shit. But the point is, prayer is not needed for good fortune. It simply happens sometimes. Am I thankful? Yes, to the people who found things and returned things. These events have renewed my faith in humanity. And in such moments, yes, Humanism is like a religion, because you kind of have a religious experience when someone you never met and never will meet does the right thing by you- extends an empathy evolved in close knit family and tribe to include someone beyond their circle of self interest. And I believe that churchgoing or not, there are lots of people who would do the right thing. And I applaud all of you for recognizing an interconnectedness among our our species (we can talk about the biosphere later) that transcends our individual experience of this life- the glory and triumph of realizing and reaching for a greater good, that benefits all. That is a "spiritual" experience Humanists revel in, yet one which requires no spirit to have. It is a sort of an intellectual epiphany. It is this selfless and noble idea, fortunately not uncommon, that has ensured the "golden rule" has been enshrined in many religions. I think the good part of religion is an effort to multiply that idea, and inasmuch as it succeeds in doing so, has a contribution to make to the potential social evolution of our species (the other selfish, violent "evil" animal instincts also clearly in play). However, the social control and institutional aspects of many religions, and their infection by self-interested control freaks, tug at the coattails of that good.

Sunday, August 4, 2013

the new age dinner guest

The Northwest is a hotbed of new age baloney. This is what happens when the Beatles go to India and hang out with a guru and add some sitars to their music; a whole generation of Westerners throw off the yoke of Christianity, only to rush headlong into the supernatural juju of other continents. Sufism, Buddhism, Hinduism, that sort the usual favorites. And the idolizing of the native, an unsubstantiated respect for indigenous "knowledge" and other forms of "traditional" knowledge, the sort born of thousands of years of tradition or simple intuition- "women's" knowing another that need not be beacked by any evidence to be asserted around here. And most often, this insidious snake oil slides by in a way that is not convenient to question- it's just part of the general lahar of granola that washed over this region years ago and is still choking innocent babies in its uber-natural wake (I refer here to the anti-vaccine hippies, and Steve Jobs' non-invasive 'treatment' choices).

Here's how it rolled out at dinner recently. A Seattle guest, vegetarian, lets drop that some years back she had a friend who was diagnosed with cancer. The tumor was enormous, running from the brainstem past all major organs to the stomach. Doctors gave the woman a 1 in 10 chance of survival. That's the setup. Are you ready for the new age cure?

New Age dinner guest quit her job to care for her (this establishes a moral high ground in terms of commitment to the patient), and put her on a special diet. The doctors thought this diet was nuts (establishes her radical anti-establishment cred). And, lo and behold, the cancer goes into remission, and the woman is still with us 17 years later.

This turd dropped into the punchbowl of conversation with a murmuring of 'wow', but not much else. It wasn't my house, and I had previously endangered my friendship with the host by pointing out that many traditional Chinese medicines are laced with heavy metals and pharmaceuticals and by the way the diagnosis and treatment is completely inconsistent and based on an unproven theories of Qi energy and Yin and Yang, so I kept my lips zipped. But I was shocked at the uncritical response.

She inferred that the diet was the cure without coming out and saying it; which is all for the better. Because the other distinct possibility is that the woman in question was the lucky 1 in 10 who survives. What I wish I had done: ok, 10 dinner guests, ok, I have a secret number in my head between 1 and 10. Eveyone pick a number between 1 and 10, and tell me your number- no repeats. No, no, no, no, YES! You survived, all the rest of you are dead. Oh, and what are you eating tonight? Looks like some meat on the plate there. Repeat after me: correlation is not causation. Correlation is not causation.

What an incredible case study. Let's assume all the facts are straight and we verified all the details. What you have is a single case study. Let me give you another case study: my mom. My mom wanted to quit smoking. She heard acupuncture could help. She went to an acupuncturist, and the quack put needles in her ears and wherever the magical meridians are for the nerves and arteries that allegedly connect to that 'wanna smoke' part of your brain, or your Qi energy, or whatever. My mom still smokes. Proof that acupuncture is a bunch of hooey? It is if you base your conclusions on anecdotes. All it takes for a lot of people is a good narrative; we like stories. We learned for thousands of years through stories; then we figured out how to do systematic, controlled research. We figured out that our intuition is often wrong.

Nobody even asked what the miracle diet consisted of. Was it of her own invention? Then she should publish it! Did she borrow it from other sources? Then give them credit! Meat is known to raise risk of developing cancer; veggies and fiber and fruits known to lower it. But what research has been done on remission in this regard? Any double-blind studies with thousands of cases?

I'm not disregarding the notion that a vegetarian diet has great health benefits- the evidence on that is solid. But don't waltz into dinner claiming you cured cancer. It makes anything else you say harder to swallow than the charbroiled meat.   

Thursday, March 15, 2012

The sanctity of life

There are certain stock phrases that are kicked around the American Christospere repeatedly. These, for some reason, provoke almost agitated questioning in my mind. Christian euphemism, pithy sayings and pious proclamations evoke the same question outright: says who? God. Which one? The only one. Are you serious? Yes, we have a book that proves everything. God provides, and life is sacred.

Life is sacred.

First off, which life? Just humans, and screw the rest of creation? No, we are stewards of all that. Now there is a great plan! Hey, bible devotees, we have been fruitful and multiplied. Life is sacredish and all, but the petri dish is getting stinky. anyway, what of the animals? Sure, josses' little kittie is up in heaven, but what about a pet bird? rat? Wild rat? Cockroach? Bacteria? Plant? Mold? Which life is sacred exactly? And even if people are special to god, his messed up image and all that, can the rest of life on the planet be sort of sacred or special too?

Second obviously related question, what does sacred mean? I thin it means, some idea or word that if you don't buy it or show it public obeisance, you are shunned or even attacked. You burn a Koran, you get knifed or a riot erupts in Butfukistan or whatever. Respect the prophet!!! Uh.. Who? Why? You are offended? How old was Aisha, the prophet's favorite wife? If my wife is disobedient I can beat her? Hey, we are both offended, let's call it even and seek common ground as best we can.

Some Christians are almost offended that I exist; you know, that I would openly say that I don't believe in any god or gods or metaphysical hoobie joobies. Or they are simply afraid, afraid to face the world without their imaginary friend and jello socials. My dears, we can still have donuts and jello together. We can even talk ethics and family. But these folks truly believe that without the wisdom of their particular book and th e bizarre human sacrifice deal it involves, that the world is lost. I get it. Jesus people are often very nice, and the feeling that modern culture is lost and the desire to hue to tradition are all strong, especially in times of change. But the world is in fact a cold and random place. We have to do our collective best to get on with it.

Anyway, there you have it. Even if life isn't sacred, you still have to hand it tot the big man in the sky for those few creations he hasn't extinguished yet. Like liverflukes, and malaria. River blindness. All things bright and beautiful!

Life is sacred. Thus all the miscarriages.

Forgive me for not buying any of it: jeebus, Krishna, sun god, tree spirit, Barney, captain America or ghosts or angels or tooth fairies. Great for children's stories, but once one reaches what George carlin called the age of reason, one moves off the arc. Permanently.

Come out as an atheist


Out

Thursday, December 8, 2011

God will provide

many of the posts here will serve as a relief valve. there are many moments that, as a rational being, one of my theist friends or colleagues smiles and says something which apparently brings them great peace, perhaps not realizing that their casual dropping of the g word or their pat pious phrase causes me excruciating intellectual pain. Or, perhaps they are well aware of this pain but seek to torment me, or, knowing of my atheism, drop little breadcrumbs which they hope will lead me to their moldy, petrified loaf of bronze-age wisdom. "god will provide" is one such phrase I was forced to countenance recently, in response to my concern that a friend was putting themselves out with their generosity. God will provide. Indeed. If god had provided, you would not be writing a check for $100.00 to help out. God will provide. Indeed, to European Americans like you and I, your god apparently delights in providing. Take your beatific smile and fine phrase over to sub-Saharan Africa and tell it to the mother whose baby has just died of malnutrition. God will provide! Except when he doesn't, which is a lot of the time. the usual theist response is that god does provide-in fact, there is enough food to go around- but it is up to us to be godly and loving enough to share it, and we fail in that, and our human corruption is why so many suffer. There is truth in those allegations, but this does not let god off the hook. How is it that a compassionate god allows innocent children to suffer because adults are ungodly? That in his bestowing of blessings-you know, have a blessed day, I am blessed, god bless America, god is so capricious in distributing his blessings? Africa is less blessed or divinely neglected at best in comparison to the USA, despite being a very religious continent. Just like Rick perry, they love god but it apparently isn't mutual, at least not in terms of the blessings that would make most of feel lucky- er, I mean, blessed. It's really the same thing when you think about it. Hordes of mexicans pray to the virgin of Guadalupe, who is especially pure on account of not having sex, which is a sexist old testament obsession for another post. But think about it. If every Mexican who prayed to the virgin got what they prayed for, they wouldn't call them miracles anymore. It is only because lots of people pray and only a select few get what they ask for that such things are called blessings or miracles. And why are some prayers answered and others ignored? Some people born with plenty and others into disease and starvation? This is a mystery that the best theologians tell us we will only be privileged to understand, if we are lucky, after we die. I once met a woman who said that she is the sort of person who always needs to know "why" things are happening...as if every event in her life has a cosmic micromanager. How sad. The only way she found peace was through a book that reassured her she might get to know god's reasons when she died. So, in other words, god may seem so capricious that events in the world appear to be random. And, lacking any rational narrative for them, your experience of them will in fact be just that-random and lacking any reason. And the best comfort you can hope for, the thing that allows you to sleep at night, is to trust that there is a reason you might learn of later...and until then you have to accept not knowing. How those clumsy intellectual gymnastics bring anyone peace is beyond me. allow me to apply occam's razor: there is no why. Accept that and stop asking. Saves a step and eliminates the uncertainty of maybe not finding out when you die! Life is random, god does not bless people or care who will win the football game- so stop thanking him. And when you rescue some miners from miles under the rock, don't forget to give credit to the human engineers who designed the capsule that got you out- unless you prefer to sit and wait while people pray for you to miraculously emerge. All of the miracles of modern medicine, including cures to diseases supposedly created by god, were made by men. And that is the true blessing; we bless ourselves, while gods flit about in the imagination and lay entombed in stone monuments to whichever mythology is currently fashionable. Zeus bless you.

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

"God will provide."

Haven't posted for a while; but that just means I have a backlog of rants. So here they come!

On good days, when I am feeling the love of being alive and the joy of human fellowship, I wax brief in Facebook posts about it. But then there are the other moments; no, not the ones where people are rude, or drive aggressively, or walk past dying people without batting an eye. Those things disappoint me, but they don't get my goat. The world is a cold, tough place and manifesting love seems surprisingly hard to cultivate in our species in public settings or outside one's in-group. No, the other moments that stimulate my writing are the passing encounters with well-meaning Christians (and a few who know I am an athiest and take some pleasure, or imagine some future salvation, in sort of poking me with their faith). They say things that are common enough but which truly get my goat by confounding any attempt at reason. There are four I will focus on, and they are interconnected: "God will provide", "Everything happens for a reason," various characterizations of people as "blessed", and "God has a plan for you." All these phrases make my brain convulse. If I could claim that such language was against my religion, I would- because I feel my intelligence insulted whenever I hear them. Your religion offends me.

First thing is first: quite often, God will NOT provide. Over 10 million children die each year from hunger: which is precisely why the UN and countless charities, many of them Christian, have to step in and fill the gap. So, who provides? People. Certainly these people are well-intentioned; and I have not seen any Atheist food banks in town (Dear fellow Atheists, put up or shut up as far as 'we are also ethical people'. We should be emulating the Christians on this front, just minus the ridiculous notion that a god is needed to feel love or teach us to share.) But it doesn't matter if god told you to share, or krishna, or you just thought it would be nice. God allowed lots people to be born without a pot to shit in, and as added insult, without any food to digest into shit. So how about this: God will provide, except when he doesn't, in which case people can help out. That is what churches do when they organize, do fund raisers, and then donate the proceeds. People do all that, yet they sell themselves short and give all the glory to god. God did not cure Polio; he created it, and we beat it with science. God is bringing beautiful babies into being in regions infested with the beautiful mosquitoes that carry the beautiful malaria he created; and man is busy trying to fix it. But who did they thank when they pulled the Chilean miners to safety? You guessed it. How about thanking the engineers who rigged the capsule? Same damn thing whenever they interview a quarterback after a football game; as if god was up there picking teams and calling plays. People are lucky, and unlucky; shit happens, some good, some bad, some predictable, and some highly unlikely. None of this indicates divine intervention. News flash: roughly 50 percent of football teams will lose; the others will win; and a few will tie. There will be some amazing plays from time to time, but god isn't "blessing" any of those criminals, unless you count their salary. And that brings us to blessings.

Have a blessed day. I am blessed. Sure you are! God will provide, especially if you are born in a developed country, even more likely if you are white. The notion that there is a conscious being up there passing out the good luck and bad luck is patently offensive, because of his inequitable distribution. I mean, you have this all-powerful, all-intelligent being, capable of miracles, who supposedly loves each one of us, possibly from the moment of conception (though that makes all the miscarriages hard to explain), and yet he can't even manage to have us all born where there is enough food to go around, or for the food to grow decently where the people are. But wait, you say, there is enough food produced to feed the world; the PEOPLE are to blame for not sharing it. That is an interesting proposition, one that is paraphrased on the cover of the weekly newsletter my wife brought home from her church: "God give us all, then calls on us to Share (superfluous capitalization theirs)." Omniscient, omnipotent, but doesn't do distribution. Leaves that to us. That is a sick little game, isn't it? Almost as sick as what he did to Abraham. But not the sickest! No, to truly appreciate how god blesses people- or more accurately, how people use that notion and the others listed above to handle psychological adversity- let's look at another category of misfortune: combat veterans.

Imagine running is your favorite activity in the world. But god loves you, and he has a plan for you, which goes like this: blow his legs off! Now, maybe god is just testing you. Trying to teach you a lesson. Using you to help others. Sure. Whatever works to stay positive, believe it. That is the power of faith- you can ignore the statistics and use the irrational part of your brain to believe that you can beat the odds, which, like a placebo pill reducing pain, actually increases the chance that you will succeed. The power or prayer and such are real- as real as a placebo; and I wonder if even I can access that power despite knowing it is rooted in hooey. I'm slightly jealous of those who have 'freed' themselves from rationality and accessed this power (along with a raft of steaming camel crap like creationism, faith healing frauds, and so on). This god sure has a funny way of blessing people- I mean, sure, the lucky veteran is the one who made it home- they are certainly more blessed than the dead- or those who made it home and then died. What a blessing! What a plan! But that's ok, they are in heaven. See, you can't lose with this god, no matter what he dishes out! There is a great benefit to looking on the bright side, and no one is better at this than the Jesus people. But more on "everything happens for a reason" and looking on the bright side and counting "blessings" and luck vs. miracles later. It is time to baptize the porcelain with a wave of my staff.

Saturday, May 21, 2011

The world is random, yet beautiful

The ideas that life evolved by events of chance, and the idea that events in our life happen randomly (without a divine reason) seem to threaten a lot of people. I will expound on that more later- it requires the mathematics of probability and some psychology to unravel. For the moment, I just want to explain my choice of banner- a fern, generated from a not terribly complex equation, plus lots of randomness- fractals.

http://bioquest.org/esteem/esteem_details.php?product_id=249

The biological world certainly does have the appearance of design- complex parts functioning in complex wholes. And it is difficult to imagine such structures appearing by chance- mainly because it is hard to conceptualize the time scale involved in evolution. But this fern, along with snowflakes and other crystals, proves that random inputs, given a few natural constraints, will form an apparent order organically, through a reiterative process, with beautiful results. Randomness is the opposite of design. But it does not occur in a vacuum; there are laws of physics and chemistry and such. How structures began to reproduce themselves, thus becoming "life", remains a mystery; but one thing is clear- given time and energy, randomness can "create" something beautiful.

Acting for a more reasonable world

This blog is not an attack on religion; but it is a positive effort in support of reason. Unfortunately, there is persistent and pernicious propaganda which continues to equate atheism with an assumed lack of values ("moral compass", and an unending flow of shoddy logic and uncritical thinking which seeks to prop up old mythologies, most pervasive among them Christianity, and most annoying of that cult the literalist and evangelical brands.

I am not hostile to Christianity per se; I have many Christian friends who are very positive people and whose faith seems to ground them personally. In fact, I am married to a practicing Catholic. Oddly enough, we both believe in love, in helping our fellow humans, and in our daily affairs give our life on this earth a higher priority than whatever afterlife may or may not await. Most Christians make great neighbors- as do most atheists, especially those of us who identify as secular humanists. Religions, like belly buttons, would be irrelevant were they not constantly thrust in our faces and inserted into politics by an apocalyptic, fear-driven band of theocrats. The sky is falling, and they have the only shelter. As always.

This blog is a release valve and a place to think out loud and work through ideas. It will explore issues of faith and the lack thereof; psychology, science, reason, skepticism, evolution and ethics. Some of the posts will inevitably be reactions to the media, to time spent sitting in Mass, etc. but there will also be random ponderings, rants (sadly, I suffer from Jesus Fatigue) and philosophical detours. I hope it provides as much pleasure to any reader who happens upon it as it does for me, the writer.

Comments and discourse are welcome, but this is a space in support of reason. Declarations of faith, readily available elsewhere, are as common as a cold rhinovirus, and just as annoying. The mental acrobatics of apologetics around ancient books can be fun, but preaching will be ridiculed or deleted here depending on my mood. Feel free to start your own blog if you want to share your Good News. My News is this: we are all on the planet together and thus interconnected; this knowledge gives us the power, and arguably responsibility, to improve our collective lot, regardless of our views on the metaphysical. I don't have faith, but I do have hope- and I don't need a mythical dead-resurrected dude or an invisible watcher in the sky to tell me to love my fellow man; we evolved to live harmoniously in small groups, and we are smart enough to extend that to the larger tribe of our species and indeed all of life. The great struggles may be painted as good vs. evil; but within that Disney narrative you will find our compassion pitted against our greed, our intelligence failing to restrain our animal biology and tribalism. Satan is not the enemy- we are. Good and evil are not external spirits, to be absorbed through sprinklings of holy water or purged through the exorcism of demons-  they are behavioral potentials to be nurtured or starved within each of us.

So let's get on with the good work of living together- rationally, please.